Readwritethink.org has 2 sets of lesson plans: one for girls and one for boys. I focused on the lesson plans for girls.
The section titled "Girls Read: Online Literature Circles" lists the following learning outcomes:
Students will
- Gain an understanding of the roles of women in diverse cultures by reading realistic fiction, set in a variety of times and places, that features strong female protagonists
- Develop skills in written expression by sharing their reactions to literature with an e-mail partner or with members of an online literature circle
- Develop skills in oral expression by sharing their reactions to literature with members of a classroom literature circle
- Participate as reflective members of an online literacy community by responding to questions and posting reviews
The majority of the work (reading/discussions) happens in the classroom context, where students form groups to read a book and then piece together what they have read with their classmates. They also perform self-evaluation in order to help them reflect on their learning processes. The evaluation form can be found here. http://www.readwritethink.org/files/resources/lesson_images/lesson970/self.pdf
Review:
1. While some forms of feminism discourage the idea of classifying literature into "boys" and "girls" literature, I like the idea of teenagers reading empowering, gender-specific literature during their formative years so that they can choose who they want to be. One of the books on the reading list, "The Breadwinner", depicts an 11-year old girl earning income to support her family in Afghanistan. It breaks down traditional roles and encourages these teenagers to think about their contributions to family and society beyond gender-defined boundaries.
2. I think the lesson plan could fit into a very Singapore/MOE context. There is both a collaborative approach to learning via the reading of books in groups, where each member reads a subdivision of the book and shares it with her peers before they read the book as a whole. There is also a move towards SDL through self-evaluation, which encourages reflection and self-improvement in their learning processes.
3. I really like the idea of contributing to an online community as part of literature. It heightens the awareness of community as part of literary appreciation, and encourages both the sharing of ideas and learning from others that enhances the literary experience. It also gives students the sense of importance as they add value to a book by sharing their learning with the wider community.
(220 words)
Hi Samuel,
ReplyDeleteI like the site you suggested and their breaking the plans into the different genders is an interesting concept. I'm not sure I like the idea of girls reading "girls' books" and vice versa as (probably like alot of feminists) I actually think that young people should be exposed to texts that are not written specifically for their gender. It does help in terms of widening perspectives but I can see that such plans will be useful for teaching gendered readings. For example, a class on feminism and/or masculinism.
Hey, yes! That did trouble me a bit, but when I saw the reading list my worries were slightly relieved.. Thankfully they're not trying to indoctrinate their female students into socially defined roles, but to help them to negotiate those roles through texts which potentially subvert gender roles.
DeleteOn the other hand, the choice of "Courage" for boys did look very gender-biased.. why not explore the theme of "Courage" for girls too? The lesson plan for guys looked like it was a lot more stereotyping!
Definitely, as you have suggested, classes on both feminism and masculinism to achieve a balanced view would be the best way to adapt their lesson plans, I agree! :)
Readwritethink is interesting in that it is based on research, and the articles are linked. Gives you the background for the suggestions. Agree that while these suggestions are good, we must be careful not to only limit girls to girl books and boy to boy books. There is a need to expand the vision of both boys and girls!
ReplyDeleteHi Samuel,
ReplyDeleteI completely agree with your point #1. Despite its obvious limitations, gender-specific novels, taught especially in an all girls or all boys classroom, will be therapeautic for students and help them work through issues faced by teenagers. The teacher can conduct focus discussions for students to engage in and participate. It is also great that the books are of an empowering nature!